Old Man of The Mountain - Issue Summary

The Old Man of The Mountain has fallen - what next?

Issue Facts

The Old Man of The Mountain has fallen - what next?By: Honorable Steve Merrill, Governor of New Hampshire, 1993-1997 
This issue has been updated by LFDA editors.
 
Early in the morning of May 3, 2003, the unthinkable happened to the beloved state symbol of the Granite State, the Old Man of the Mountain. It came crashing down.
 
The Old Man was created over 10,000 years ago by the last geologic ice age that retreated back toward the North Pole. Interesting geologic patterns, such as the Old Man, were created on the retreating side of the ice flow. Thus, the Old Man faced south into the Pemigewasset Valley in Franconia State Park. It was 45 feet high, 26 feet wide, and weighed 15,000 lbs.
 
The Old Man was appreciated by Native American Indians for centuries, then by the first surveyors who described the phenomenon in 1805. Written about by Nathaniel Hawthorne in 'The Great Stone Face', the outcropping became beloved in New Hampshire. It became our state seal, it appeared on the New Hampshire quarter, and countless commemoratives over the years. In a powerfully emotional sense, it was New Hampshire.
 
Initial public sentiment was strongly in favor of replacing the face with a man-made structure. Entrepreneurs and engineers testified in favor of their own concept. Metal, plastic, Plexiglas, stone and cement replicas were described and suggested.
               

Options for the Old Man project

I. The Old Man Restoration Task Force (in which I served as Chair) was created by Governor Craig Benson and comprised of interested state officials and the state’s capable geologist, David Wunsch. After months of testimony and visits to the site, the Task Force recommended: a) no replica should be placed on the face of the mountain, b) creation of $5 million Old Man of the Mountain Legacy Fund museum near Profile Lake; c) construction of a tribute made of five large stones that would recreate the famous image from the viewer’s vantage point at the memorial.
 
II. Architects Proposal - Francis Treves, a New Jersey architect believes the Task Force did not go far enough. He has proposed a 45 foot glass and steel structure for the face of the mountain. The Treves design, which won an award in 2009 from the New Hampshire chapter of the American Institute of Architects, would feature 250 suspended glass panels, an interior sky walk, and a waterfall created from diverted rainwater. Such a project would clearly attract attention and interest.
 
III. Legislative Activity - In 2009 two bills (HB 192 and HB 603) were introduced to generate interest and support for  a monument on or near the mountain. Both bills failed to pass the House.

Organizers broke ground June 24, 2010 on the first phase of the memorial. It includes a lakeside pavilion and stainless steel "profilers" that will recreate the outline of the Old Man. The first phase was completed as scheduled in June 2011.

(Photos courtesy Lorna Colquhoun/Union Leader)

Phase 2 includes a series of huge granite stones that, when viewed from a raised platform, merge to create the Old Man's profile.

(Illustration courtesy NH.gov)


2013 updates

The project to create a memorial plaza to the Old Man hit a snag in April, when donations effectively dried up. Board member Dick Hamilton told The Associated Press: "Fundraising has basically come nearly to a halt because of the economy, so there will be no phase two," he said. "Basically, what we have there now, we're going to finish up, polish up, add some benches and some signage and then go away."

Show More
Pop Up
Pros

Pro Issue Opinion by Honorable Steve Merrill, for a monument on the face of the mountain:

 
  • Tourism is critical to this area of the state and only a replica on the face of the mountain will bring visitors to the Old Man memorial. As time passes, the economic impact of the loss of the Old Man will only increase.
  • Architect Francis Treves' award-winning glass and steel model will create significant publicity during the construction phase and will bring thousands of tourists to see the remarkable structure.
  • Even the legislative proposals acknowledge that private funds will be needed, thus assuring that the Old Man re-creation will not become yet another government-sponsored program.
Show More
Pop Up
Cons

Con Issue Opinion by the Honorable Steve Merrill, against a monument on the face of the mountain:

 
  • Unlike Mt. Rushmore, the Old Man was made up of several overhanging blocks of granite, not one single solid piece. Few outside of those involved knew how precarious the Old Man's perch truly was, and it is impractical to try to reproduce it.
  • Since 1954 state geologists and interested citizens did their best to keep the Old Man on its granite perch. Holes were drilled, hooks and cables attached. Epoxy resin and cement were used to block up particularly troublesome fissures. A stone replacement will undoubtedly require the same effort.
  • The Task Force concluded after months of deliberation and testimony, that nature created the Old Man and that any man-made structure on the face of the mountain would not be in keeping with the New Hampshire tradition.
Show More
Pop Up
Old Man of the Mountain Member Posts
Take Action

If you are interested in making a suggestion as to what to do about the Old Man of the Mountain, contact the Friends of the Old Man of the Mountain/Franconia Notch.
 
PO Box 375
Concord, NH 03302

Phone: 603-218-6703
 
Email: Oldmanlegacyfund@comcast.net

Show More
Pop Up

Join the Discussion on Facebook

Learn More/Take Action

The Old Man of The Mountain has fallen - what next? Whatever your thoughts are, we urge you to make your voice heard. See the "Learn More/Take Action" section on this page for more information.

Issue Status

The Old Man of The Mountain Legacy Fund's process of building a monument to the Old Man of The Mountain has come to an end, according to the Union Leader. Though first phase was completed in June 2011, and the fund reached about $500,000, donations have trailed off and are not sufficient to continue the next phase.

The first phase of the memorial, completed in 2011, includes a series of steel rods that when viewed from a certain angle, show an outline of the profile against the cliff.

The second phase, which was disbanded, called for five granite monoliths to be situated in such a way that when viewed in sequence from a raised platform, they would appear to merge into one image resembling the outline of the Old Man.

Legacy Fund Chairman Dick Hamilton of Littleton said on April 24, 2013 his group has voted to halt any further work at the site.